Sierra Day sentenced to life in prison without parole for murder of Aniya Day-Garrett, Deonte Lewis eligible for parole after 20 years

Sierra Day sentenced to life in prison without parole for murder of Aniya Day-Garrett, Deonte Lewis eligible for parole after 20 years
Sierra Day and Deonte Lewis at sentencing, Aniya Day-Garrett (Source: WOIO)

CLEVELAND, OH (WOIO) - Sierra Day, the mother of slain Aniya Day-Garrett, and her boyfriend Deonte Lewis were both sentenced to life in prison for the murder of the 4-year-old girl.

Day was sentenced without the possibility for parole, while Lewis will be eligible for parole after serving 20 years in prison.

Both were found guilty on eight charges that include aggravated murder and permitting child abuse.

Mickhal Garrett delivers empassioned speech at Sierra Day, Deonte Lewis sentencing

Judge Timothy McCormick, who presided over the couple’s trial, sentenced both during Wednesday’s hearing.

“In my 24 years, I don’t think I’ve seen such a callous disregard for human life that Sierra showed Aniya,” McCormick stated before delivering the sentence.

Judge sentences Sierra Day, Deonte Lewis

Mickhal Garrett, Aniya’s biological father, addressed the courtroom with a victim impact statement while standing before Day and Lewis.

“Sierra Day, Aniya’s birth mother, how could you torture and murder your own flesh and blood. Your daughter, my beautiful princess, my angel, my perfect Aniya,” Garrett said.

Mickhal Garrett, Aniya's biological father, delivers victim impact statement at sentencing

Day did not speak, but her boyfriend did address the courtroom after his attorney’s request to dismiss all of his charges was denied. His words of “I loved Aniya” fell on deaf ears. They rang hollow because he watched as she suffered a slow starvation that reduced her to skin and bones.

Day refused to ask for mercy, choosing not to comment when the judge asked her.

Deonte Lewis speaks after attorney's request to drop charges is denied

Thirty-eight witnesses were called to the stand during the murder trial that spanned six days. The jury delivered a guilty verdict less than 24 hours after closing arguments concluded.

“Aniya never stood a chance at life with a mother like Sierra Day,” said Cuyahoga County Prosecutor Michael O’Malley. “Day and her boyfriend Deonte Lewis were held responsible today for the physical abuse and persistent and unfathomable neglect that led to Aniya’s death.”

Paramedics and police investigators were called to Day’s Euclid apartment in March 2018 after receiving a call that the 4-year-old girl was not breathing.

Noticeable burns and bruises were observed on Aniya’s body.

She was taken to Euclid General Hospital where she was pronounced dead.

Copyright 2019 WOIO. All rights reserved.