Easement confusion leaves homeowner with tree over his head - Cleveland 19 News Cleveland, OH

Easement confusion leaves homeowner with tree over his head

NASHVILLE, TN (WSMV) -

One Nashville homeowner knows what it feels like to have something hanging over his head, and the garage where he restores antique cars and motorcycles is one big storm away from becoming rubble.

Terry Walls said a big, leaning hackberry tree near his garage appears to be on Metro Nashville property, but through a strange twist of legal events, nobody is claiming responsibility for the tree.

"My garage is going to get crushed," Walls said.

For now, the tree is kept upright by a couple of chains, and it appears the tree is on the Metro Nashville easement. It's not on Walls' deed, and its location is marked as an easement or alley.

Metro Councilman Tony Tenpenny has been calling everyone in government for a solution.

"I would love to see Metro and my constituent come to some kind of agreement. I believe they really could work this out between the two of them. If this thing falls, and he's in there, we are probably going to a funeral," Tenpenny said.

However, Metro said while the spot may have been designed as an easement, the city never accepted it as an easement. So, that makes it private property, and Metro Public Works cannot legally cut down the tree.

"We are bound by law. The government is not allowed to spend public tax dollars on private property. We would be breaking the law to do that," said Mark Macy, Public Works assistant director of engineering.

Now, the tree that is still not on Walls' property truly is his problem, which could cost $1,800 to have removed.

"I've been a machinist and mechanic for 30-plus years and am currently jobless. I have a little money, but $1,800 is a good chunk on me unemployed," Walls said.

Walls' insurance company said it can't do anything until after the tree actually falls. Walls said it's going to be difficult to come up with the money for removing the tree, but he said it would be foolish to wait to collect insurance money and build another garage.

Copyright 2013 WSMV (Meredith Corporation). All rights reserved.

  • Seen on 19Seen on 19More>>

  • What you need to know about Cleveland's Women's march this Saturday

    What you need to know about Cleveland's Women's march this Saturday

    Tuesday, January 16 2018 4:44 PM EST2018-01-16 21:44:57 GMT
    Women's March in D.C. in 2017. (Source: Wikipedia)Women's March in D.C. in 2017. (Source: Wikipedia)

    On Saturday women will gather on Public Square, and around the country, to march for women's rights. Last year a massive estimated crowd of 500,000 took their message to the streets of Washington D.C. to bring awareness to issues of legislation and policies regarding human rights, including women's rights, immigration reform, healthcare reform, reproductive rights and the natural environment. 

    More >>

    On Saturday women will gather on Public Square, and around the country, to march for women's rights. Last year a massive estimated crowd of 500,000 took their message to the streets of Washington D.C. to bring awareness to issues of legislation and policies regarding human rights, including women's rights, immigration reform, healthcare reform, reproductive rights and the natural environment. 

    More >>
  • How you can work from home for Apple

    How you can work from home for Apple

    Tuesday, January 16 2018 12:22 PM EST2018-01-16 17:22:33 GMT
    (File)(File)

    What sounds better than getting paid to work all from the comfort of your couch? Apple is hoping the answer to that question is 'nothing'.

    More >>

    What sounds better than getting paid to work all from the comfort of your couch? Apple is hoping the answer to that question is 'nothing'.

    More >>
  • Euclid man up for America's favorite crossing guard

    Euclid man up for America's favorite crossing guard

    Tuesday, January 16 2018 12:17 PM EST2018-01-16 17:17:16 GMT
    Frank Macuga leads the way in national crossing guard competition. (Source: WOIO)Frank Macuga leads the way in national crossing guard competition. (Source: WOIO)

    Who's America's favorite crossing guard? Frank Macuga of Euclid is one of the finalists in a national crossing guard competition to figure that out.  

    More >>

    Who's America's favorite crossing guard? Frank Macuga of Euclid is one of the finalists in a national crossing guard competition to figure that out.  

    More >>
Powered by Frankly